Liberal democrats and the mainstream media have been incredibly quick to bash President Bush and the Federal Government for their handling of the rescue efforts in New Orleans. Sid Blumenthal, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. , and Molly Ivins shots off condemnation pieces within 24 hours of this tragedy, revealing their true colors once again. Hillary Rodham Clinton is calling for a 9/11-style investigation of Katrina, seeking to point fingers and cause disruption for the President and the Republican party. They are cheap opportunists and the very worst kind of snake oil salesmen.
So what's the bottom line?
Did the President make all the right choices? I don't think so. But he has been confronted with choices that no President has had to make before! Now there have been TWO major disasters on U.S. soil on his watch. It's not his fault, it's just the way it is. I hope Americans are not stupid enough to blame him for 9/11 and for Hurricane Katrina. Say it isn't so...
All things considered, things in New Orleans have improved DRAMATICALLY. In fact, it's going from chaos to organized chaos. Not bad for one week.
While people are pointing fingers at Mr. Bush and the feds, they actually help to illustrate the point that conservatives and Republicans have been stating again and again.
Government is NOT your daddy, and cannot save you from things like these. Government is the LAST group you want to depend on to save your life when you have other options.
In this case, people did have other options.
Ask New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin why he did not deploy the hundreds of buses to evacuate the poor and elderly from the city when he could have?

There they are, just soaking up the water. The could have and SHOULD have been used to rescue the people that were trapped.
Ask Louisiana Governor Kathleen Blanco why the established plan for something like this was not executed. Ask her why there was not food, water and security at the Superdome.
Louisiana has been a democrat-controlled state for my lifetime and then some. The response to this tragedy, and the fact that there are so many poor people in New Orleans to begin with, is more a reflection on the failed policies of the Democrat party than anything else.
the liberals can point fingers at the President and Republicans all they want, but I guarantee you that if Rudy Guiliani were the Mayor of New Orleans and Jeb Bush were the Governor of Louisiana, the adults would have been in the house, and they would have handled this tragedy far better.
It is time to bring an end to the entitlement mentality that even allow people to depend on Government for anything more than guaranteeing the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

September 6, 2005 04:51 PM
And what of President Bush's dim bulb of a mother who today is being quoted about her visit to the Houston Astrodome as saying: "Almost everyone I’ve talked to says we're going to move to Houston."
Then she added: "What I’m hearing which is sort of scary is they all want to stay in Texas. Everyone is so overwhelmed by the hospitality.
"And so many of the people in the arena here, you know, were underprivileged anyway, so this--this (she chuckles slightly) is working very well for them."
Did Mrs. Bush maybe forget about the thousands of deaths, the complete loss of houses, businesses, jobs, and lives along the way here? And you're telling me that it's the Republicans that are "the adults" in this situation, Joel?
It'd be nice to get beyond the political mudslinging and try to understand what went well, what went poorly and how to fix it. For years academics and local government officials had been telling the Feds that they needed more money to fix the levee system and hurricane preparedness. What happened with that? And what makes you think that the Astrodome should have had food and water for over 15,000 people just sitting in storerooms anyway?
September 6, 2005 05:43 PM
Wow, who rang your bell? Oh yeah.. that would be me. ;-)
I didn't hear Barb's comments, nor the context. Regardless, I've never been a fan of hers so they don't really matter to me.
I don't think it is the Fed's job to fix the levee system. That is a local issue to be handled with local dollars.
And why would they have food and supplies in the Astrodome? I know, you meant the Superdome. The Superdome was the contigency plan. They were not ready to implement the plan that they had already decided on. Poor planning.
And you know, I'm no diehard Republican, though I am conservative. And I believe Bush has made plenty of decisions that are contrary to what I believe. I agree that the finger pointing should not be taking place.
But the bottom line? They started it. And rest assured that they will continue it.
September 6, 2005 05:48 PM
I think you would feel differently if it was your family left to die in the heat needlessly. They knew the storm was coming and the government did nothing! To say Bush is facing things no other president has ever had to face is just factually wrong. There have been countless disasters faced for hundreds of years in this country. I will never understand the willingness of Bush supporters to forgive him for mistake after mistake. Mistakes that end with dead Americans.
These were Americans who did not die from the storm, rather they DIED OF STARVATION because nobody came for them. This includes little innocent babies. And yes, that IS the responsibility of the federal government to get these people out.
I don’t see how you can make such heartless and insensitive comments and still call yourself a Christian. I thought you were pro life?
Call others partisan all you want but I think you have exposed yourself to be as partisan as they come.
September 6, 2005 08:12 PM
"not bad for one week" you say?
You must be kidding. The federal government let Americans sit and starve for 4 to 5 full days before they did anything to help. People died Joel.
You say don't point fingers and yet that is all you do. Typical right wing hypocrisy.
I hope your town never gets hit by terrorists and you need your government to help you and your precious white family survive. According to you that isn’t the job of homeland security though. Don’t you see the big picture?
September 6, 2005 09:36 PM
Mike and Cathy, I believe you misunderstand me. What happened in the gulf states IS a tragedy and I believe people DID die needlessly. Did you know it took the government 4-5 days to mobilize into NYC after the terrorists struck? Bureaucracy moves slooooowly. There are some things the government is not equipped to do.
Did Bush blow it? Yes, I think he did. And the Mayor. And the Governor. And the point of my post was not to point fingers. It was to show how the liberals started pointing fingers within 24 hours!!!
The officials on the ground are the ones saying that things are getting under control and that it could have even been worse had more people not taken heed and left the city. Perhaps if more people had the mentality that THEY were responsible for their own actions instead of depending on the welfare state to rescue them, they would still be alive. The elderly and sick should have been on the BUSES that you see soaking in water on this page. THAT is why they died of starvation and heat exhaustion.
And let's straighten a couple things out. It is NOT the job of the federal government to rescue people. People are responsible for rescuing people. You will find churches and charitable organizations, not to mention courageous individuals with big hearts, to be FAR more effective at rescuing people than the bloated bureaucracy known as Washington and the incredibly corrupt New Orleans and Louisiana government. Putting your trust in government to save you is downright foolish, and this is a perfect example.
I am pro-life and I am a Christian. I AM doing something about relief efforts for the vicitms. In fact, my concern and activity has raised over $5000 in the past 48 hours. What have you done? Don't confuse analysis of the facts with any measure or lack of compassion. This is commentary, nothingmore.
My intention was not to castigate the helpless and those who lost their lives and homes. It was to point out the viciousness of the left who couldn't even wait 24 hours before blaming the President. It was to demonstrate the ineptitude of the local officials who HAD the plan on paper and didn't execute it.
And Cathy.. my town WAS hit by terrorists. I live in Oklahoma City. Enough said.
September 7, 2005 12:17 AM
Joel,
With all due respect I have to differ with your facts. It did not take 4-5 days for the government to mobilize in NY on Sept. 11. I know this because I lived in NYC at the time. It took less than 5 hours for assistance from the federal government to show up, and show up in a big way.
You claim the “liberals” started pointing fingers. Well again you are wrong. The condemnation of the response time was overwhelming and came from both sides of the isle. This is extremely well documented. Even Fox news was “pointing fingers.” By trying to pin this on the “liberals” you are guilty of politicizing the disaster which is exactly what you accuse others of doing. Those on the right (or left) who say this is not the time to “point fingers” need to get a clue. Of course it’s time to point fingers. People need to be accountable. I don’t need to see Bush on national television praising Michael Brown, the head of FEMA, when, at that exact moment, there was not a single person evacuated from the superdome or the convention center. And let’s not forget they had already been there for almost 3 days. These people were literally dying. Bush consistently rewards failure with promotions and I’m sick of it. Do you think you or I could get away with it at our jobs?
To think that we can rely on “the people” to fix a disaster of this size on their own is just childish. Citizens and organizations like churches can do a lot, but it is far from enough. Not even close. Of course we need the government to organize relief and assistance on such a grand scale. To suggest otherwise is simply insane. Is the local church going to hop in helicopters and pluck people from roofs? Is the Elks club going to pump the water from the city? Who rebuilds the roads? Who digs through the rubble removing bodies? Who supplies food and medicine.
What we need is leadership and leadership does not come from George Bush. He couldn’t even be bothered to leave his vacation until the situation was horrendous. This man continues to make piss poor decisions that lead to Americans dying needlessly. It is not only our right, but our duty to point fingers at our government. Again I ask you to imagine your family trapped in the overheated superdome, with nothing to eat, surrounded by the dead and dying, standing in human feces. That reality is enough to make “liberals” and “conservatives” alike point fingers.
September 7, 2005 12:46 AM
Mike,
I appreciate your respectful attitude and your passion. I agree that Fox and the other stations tended towards tabloid journalism during this whole thing. The site of Geraldo Rivera screaming like a madman at the Superdome made me wonder why this clown is still on TV.
Where were Ray Nagin and Kathleen Blanco? Neither showed their face at the Superdome.
Here's a fact. President Bush begged Blanco to get everyone out on Sunday.. to declare a state of emergency. She said she needed more time.. 24 hours, to decide. What's funny is Nagin is passing the blame to Blanco now. By law, Bush could NOT send the National Guard until Blanco declared a state of emergency! FEMA could not go until Blanco said so. But should Michael Brown go? Yup. He shouldn't have been there in the first place.
I am convinced that we don't know the whole story of what took place, and we may never know. At least not objectively. There will be a multitude of books, made-for-tv movies, songs and who knows what else.
Certainly, military helicopters can do their bit. Local authorities couldn't handle the looters and it took the National Guard to step in. I certainly don't mean that churches are going to rescue people from buildings, though there were many heroic people doing just that. I'm talking about the efficiency factor that is exhibited in taking care of people. And when I say "the people", I am speaking of the private sector.
Look, I have no doubt that what these people went through was beyond what anyone every thought possible in America. I can't even begin to imagine the conditions and I feel tremendous compassion for these people.
You are correct, liberals and conservatives alike will point fingers. And leadership on both sides will likely shirk their responsibility. They have their jobs to look after.
Just another reason not to trust government and get them out of our lives.
September 7, 2005 02:43 AM
Wow Joel, you stirred up a hornet's nest here. I have not much to say except that BOTH Libs and Conservatives are wrong here and the finger pointing is stupid and useless. ANYONE who politicizes a tradgedy such as this to further their party's line is disgusting. However, you say that we should end entitlement and all government help to people. Okay, then just who will help them? Has the welfare system been abused in this country? Absolutely! But to eliminate it completely might destroy any chance some have of getting the help they need to better their lives when they are born into situations less fortunate than others. Tell me, Joel, is big business and Corporate America REALLY going to help others? I think not. If you expect the private sector to REALLY give, you are out of touch with reality. CEO's of big Corporations are not going to give up their Ferrari or house in the Bahamas to feed the poor. They are ONLY concerned about the bottom line of their business. Money is their God. Corporate America is JUST as corrupt as the government. The only way that poor people may get ahead and things such as the New Orleans disaster can be handled correctly is for PEOPLE to mean more than money and for ALL to work together for the good of humanity. Call me an idealist, call me a cynic, but I know that in today's America, governnment and corporations are not ready to put people before the Holy Dollar. At least people like you and me may do so, and that is a start. If only the larger picture could learn from the smaller, huh?
September 7, 2005 10:06 AM
Again, I don’t know if you are purposefully creating facts or if you actually believe them to be true.
Other than a very few examples, like Geraldo, the media was not acting in a tabloid fashion. They were exposing human suffering and thank god they did. Who knows if Bush, FEMA and Homeland Security would have gotten off their butts without the coverage. What is tabloid about that? Geraldo is an idiot but he was an extremely small drop in a huge bucket. I am not a fan of mainstream “news” but was impressed with their coverage during the first week after the storm.
Mr. Bush did not beg anyone to do anything on Sunday. He did not acknowledge the storm until it hit on Monday. Then he went to Phoenix and then off to San Diego for a party rather than visiting the worst natural disaster to occur in America’s history. Meanwhile thousands of people were suffering. And, let me point out that, not only did Bush know they were suffering, they ENTIRE WORLD knew they were suffering. So what does he do? He does a quick fly by the next day, does nothing else and the people were still stuck there. They were trapped there for 3 more days. Bush did nothing and that is a fact.
To say that Nagin and Blanco “never showed their faces at the superdome” is once again completely false. I know you came to that decision because you hate all democrats, but come on Joel, they were two of the MOST visible people during this tragedy. No elected official was kicking and screaming louder for help then those two. And what does our fearless leader do? He snubs them in a very public way. He is such a petty little man that he sneaks into town without telling the governor he’s coming?!? What a bunch of schoolyard crap. People continue to die and huge problems remain and Bush decides to act like an 8 year old rather than lead.
I know that we could go back and forth on this issue, but why bother? You will continue to ignore the facts and simply invent things to help your argument. You complain and complain about partisan finger pointing and yet you are so blinded by your own incredible partisanship that you can’t even see that you are the biggest offender. It is so frustrating.
September 7, 2005 11:21 AM
Sorry you are frustrated Mike. Your partisan colors are glaring as well. Interesting that even liberal-lapdog CNN/Gallup have a poll...
-------------------
A CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll of 609 adults taken September 5-6 shows:
Blame Game -- 13% said George W. Bush is "most responsible for the problems in New Orleans after the hurricane"; 18% said "federal agencies"; 25% said "state and local officials"; 38% said "no one is to blame"; 6% had no opinion. -- 29% said that "top officials in the federal agencies responsible for handling emergencies should be fired"; 63% said they should not; 8% had no opinion.
MORE
Government Performance -- 10% said George W. Bush has done a "great" job in "responding to the hurricane and subsequent flooding"; 25% said "good"; 21% said "neither good nor bad"; 18% said "bad"; 24% said "terrible"; 2% had no opinion. -- 8% said federal government agencies responsible for handling emergencies have done a "great" job in "responding to the hurricane and subsequent flooding"; 27% said "good"; 20% said "neither good nor bad"; 20% said "bad"; 22% said "terrible"; 3% had no opinion. -- 7% said state and local officials in Louisiana have done a "great" job in "responding to the hurricane and subsequent flooding"; 30% said "good"; 23% said "neither good nor bad"; 20% said "bad"; 15% said "terrible"; 5% had no opinion.
---------------
And after over a week, a major news network has FINALLY realized that New Orleans had a plan that was not implemented.
Extra, extra.. read all about it.
http://www.captainsquartersblog.com/mt/archives/005392.php
Bush declared a state of emergency from Crawford on Saturday. Here's the story from the AP.
------------------------
CRAWFORD, Texas - President Bush declared a state of emergency in Louisiana on Saturday because of the approach of Hurricane Katrina and his spokesman urged residents along the coast to heed authorities' advice to evacuate.
Bush, vacationing at his ranch, was being regularly updated about the storm, which is expected to hit land early Monday, White House spokesman Scott McClellan said.
Officials from the Federal Emergency Management Agency continue to coordinate with state authorities in Florida, Mississippi, Louisiana and Alabama, and have prepositioned supplies in areas expected to be affected, he said.
The president's emergency declaration authorizes the FEMA to coordinate all disaster relief efforts and to provide appropriate assistance in a number of Louisiana parishes, or counties.
Authorities told residents of low-lying coastal communities to head for higher ground. The storm was expected to strengthen as it crosses the Gulf of Mexico and could become a Category 4 hurricane with wind of at least 131 mph.
"We urge residents in the areas that could be impacted to follow the recommendations of local authorities," McClellan said.
-----------------------
And despite the revisionistic tendenceys of liberals, the Feds WERE at work within 24 hours.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05242/562353.stm
"The federal government began rushing baby formula, communications equipment, generators, water and ice into hard-hit areas of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama, along with doctors, nurses and first-aid supplies.
The U.S. Defense Department sent experts to help with search-and-rescue operations."
------------------
September 8, 2005 10:47 AM
There are several issues here.
1. Sure, the opportunists will use the disaster to Bash Bush. They ran out of ammunition with the Iraq War so anything new will do.
2. Expecting help within 24-48 hours for an unprecedented disaster is not even realistic. Many of the rescuers couldn't even get to the place and certainly, should be available DURING the hurricane risking their own lives.
3. The Governor seem to have stated that everything was under control, not necessitating further assistance until all hell broke loose.
4. Communities should have helped those who could not help themselves to evacuate, such as the elderly, the sick and the invalids. Many tried, most failed.
5. Thousands of now "dead" people "Choose" to stay behind besides the warnings. Many even came on TV to say they were going to ride the storm. They are dead now. Their own poor choice. Cannot blame the goverment or the people for that.
6. Blaming Bush for everything is fashionable among those that hate him. That's nothing new. This kind of B.S. is not even knew in the history of this country. There will always be people blaming the President for everything.
7. People like the play victims, especially when it involves race issues. Yet, if you look closely, the majority of the rescuers and helpers are not Afro-Americans!!!! So there IS NOT racism here.
8. Being shot at is no fun when you're trying to help, regardless if it is isolated incidents or not.
9. Being raped, beaten or robbed inside the rescue dome is no fun either. What kind of crap is that? Justifiable? Never!
10. Having your store looted under the excuse of "no assistance" isn't justifiable either.
Some people bring their own demise upon themselves, then incite other to blame the President or the country for their own stupidity, ignorance or lack of reasoning. That, in my opinion, isn't fair.
September 8, 2005 10:48 AM
There are several issues here.
1. Sure, the opportunists will use the disaster to Bash Bush. They ran out of ammunition with the Iraq War so anything new will do.
2. Expecting help within 24-48 hours for an unprecedented disaster is not even realistic. Many of the rescuers couldn't even get to the place and certainly, should be available DURING the hurricane risking their own lives.
3. The Governor seem to have stated that everything was under control, not necessitating further assistance until all hell broke loose.
4. Communities should have helped those who could not help themselves to evacuate, such as the elderly, the sick and the invalids. Many tried, most failed.
5. Thousands of now "dead" people "Choose" to stay behind besides the warnings. Many even came on TV to say they were going to ride the storm. They are dead now. Their own poor choice. Cannot blame the goverment or the people for that.
6. Blaming Bush for everything is fashionable among those that hate him. That's nothing new. This kind of B.S. is not even knew in the history of this country. There will always be people blaming the President for everything.
7. People like the play victims, especially when it involves race issues. Yet, if you look closely, the majority of the rescuers and helpers are not Afro-Americans!!!! So there IS NOT racism here.
8. Being shot at is no fun when you're trying to help, regardless if it is isolated incidents or not.
9. Being raped, beaten or robbed inside the rescue dome is no fun either. What kind of crap is that? Justifiable? Never!
10. Having your store looted under the excuse of "no assistance" isn't justifiable either.
Some people bring their own demise upon themselves, then incite other to blame the President or the country for their own stupidity, ignorance or lack of reasoning. That, in my opinion, isn't fair.
September 10, 2005 07:42 AM
As a lifelong resident of south Louisiana, its' my opinion that federal, state, and city officials deserve part of the blame for the poor and slow response.
However, what I am most upset about is the fact that the corrupt, incompetent and lazy city officials, including the mayor, did so little to prepare for a hurricane like this! It is POSSIBLE to build a levy system that can withstand a category 5 hurricane! Why wasn't this done? It would have cost far less than the $100 Billion PLUS that this will cost. A flood wall is not a levy. There should be a redundant system of levy's which would act as back up when one breaks.
Being prepared for a hurricane is a local/city issue. The city of New Orleans was NOT prepared and its' lead to catastrophe and because of that it is now a national issue. The bottom line is the local officials are responsible for this whole mess. We MUST be prepared for a worst case situation!
September 12, 2005 01:51 AM
"Louisiana has been a democrat-controlled state for my lifetime and then some. The response to this tragedy, and the fact that there are so many poor people in New Orleans to begin with, is more a reflection on the failed policies of the Democrat party than anything else."
You have got to be kidding? A problem because of democratic policies??? This wasn't a failure of a particular party, this was the failure of GOVERNMENT, period.
Katrina passed by thankfully and New Orleans was still intact. But then the levy owned by the Army Corps of Engineers (i.e THE FEDS) gave way, a levy which hadn't been reinforced since 1965!
The local politicos didn't know what to do neither did the feds. They *prevented* aid from coming in, they herded people like cattle and treated them like criminals and prisoners, people starved, died and were raped in the Superdome.
Read and watch the eyewitness accounts of what was going on. The looters looted (and some of the police joined in) because the bulwark of the community had fled. Which should be a lesson to all of us why communities actually stay peaceful. Hint: it is not because of the police.
It amazes me that every time the gov't fails we want to send them even more money and give them all kinds of excuses. If a business operated that way we would rightfully blow them off. Hopefully people will learn that we cannot depend on gov't to protect us, even when it comes to so called public infrastructure. They simply do not have the right incentives to do it efficently and effectively. But to understand that requires an understanding of basic economics which unfortunately many Americans are sorely lacking in.
September 21, 2005 10:24 PM
I can see why people who don't think but just feel and act on feelings are more liberal because my mother was one of them but the mentality of depending on the government's back (you and me) for your living has come home to roost in new Orleans. These people have made a life of entitlement (free loading jerks) & dependency and it has finally been shown that if you don't do for yourself no one else will when the chips are down. So now the blame game starts but isn't it strange that none of these people are looking in the mirror and asking themselves why they were not prepared better and why they stuck around to see the water rise before they accepted the fact that it was really happening. Even though they live below sea level or lake level or what ever. who's fault is it when you are warned but don't bother to take it seriously. I say this area should be returned to swamp land and written off because you no what? The next big storm will do the exact same thing again and so will the next etc. Who owes who what here? Why should this kind of stupidity cost the rest of so much? Sure people die because they are stupid just as it is stupid to step out into traffic without looking. I have compassion for those who really could not help themselves but the rest of them? Count me out of the big easy tear jerk. Got to hand it to you Joel for standing up and saying what you said even though you know you are going to get mud slung at you for this. I feel exactly the same way. All I can say is right on and keep thinking the "right" way.